Skip to content

Solve your Counter Intelligence and Security problems by empowering your people

I’ve just returned from this year’s RAF Counter Intelligence and Security Conference. I was struck by some recurring themes that I see across domains – albeit cast into really stark relief by this security perspective.

Everyone was in total agreement on the context;

  • It’s a tremendously complex and challenging environment with a live adversary
  • We’re held back by silos/stovepipes/pillars (or your buzzword of choice for organisational boundaries at any level)
  • We’ve not done enough in the past, and we’re not moving fast enough now to keep pace with the challenges

So, the ‘what’ and the ‘why’ were both really clear. And also that we need to do something different. More of the same simply won’t work. What was less clear was the ‘how’. If we’re to do something different, what is it? And what is it that’s stopped us doing it already?

We think these are intrinsically linked. Emerging the ‘how’ is bound up in identifying and resolving the threats and impediments that prevent progress. We should do this by turning these weaknesses into virtues – in three key areas.

Elimination of Risk into Management of Risk

The biggest factor is the futile pursuit of the elimination of risk. Successful change, particularly in Defence, is often accompanied by a strong forcing factor. This enables a high risk appetite that’s well managed as part of the delivery. Conversely, attempts to minimise or even eliminate risk from change activity invariably results in delay or failure.

This is even more imperative when we consider this in the Defence and Security domain. Attempts to reduce risk to near zero early in a programme simply result in a shift of that risk to the Operator or Warfighter – unforgivable, but sadly all too common.

The opportunity here is for leaders to accept that going faster and taking more risk now is actually what reduces risk over the long term, rather than attempting to minimise risk up front and ultimately slowing delivery.

Centralisation into Decentralisation

Another thing on which everyone agreed was the size of the challenge for Defence in securing its enormous attack surface. Particularly when you consider the wider ecosystem with Industry and partners. There are some security truisms here that we’ve always known;

  • You can’t protect everywhere (‘They who defend everything, defend nothing.’ Frederick the Great)
  • Adversaries only need to be lucky once, you need to be lucky every time
  • You must assume there will be breaches and have ways to handle them

The common approach has been the establishment of a central team, with total responsibility for all of this. And as it gets harder, the reaction is to bolster that central team. We’d argue that it was always impossible for a central team to manage this environment, and that the increasing complexity, rate of change and increasingly contested space now makes that case even more strongly.

Here, the flip is to pivot these central teams from ‘doers’ to ‘enablers’. Make them smaller, and use that freed up resource to innovate, decentralise and empower everyone else in the organisation (more on that later).

Procurement of Outputs into Delivery of Outcomes.

When faced with a complex problem, for which there are no easy solutions, it’s only human nature to grasp for silver bullets or too-good-to-be-true offers. In this domain this frequently comes in the purchase of this or that technology, toolset or technical consultancy. The complex problem persists, because the tool was never the problem in the first place.

The reaction is often to blame the pace of procurement, and attempt to speed it up through more technical consultancy, or another tool. This again has limited impact – a new tool will be impacted by your organisational impediments as much as the old one, however quickly and efficiently you’ve delivered it.

Pivoting to the definition, delivery, and measurement of outcomes rather than outputs is the opportunity here. It’s the transition that is often hardest for organisations to make, as it is a fundamental change in mindset, culture and way of working.

How?

You would be forgiven for reading this far and thinking were still missing a lot of the ‘how?’ mentioned at the start. The good news is that this how almost certainly already exists within your organisation, in the hidden knowledge amongst your teams. They likely already know what needs to be done, or have sufficient hypotheses and ideas that will emerge the solutions that work for your individual organisation.

As a leader, with the power to change the system, your role is really simple:

  • Give your teams intent (in the form of outcomes, not solutions)
  • Give them the resources necessary to meet that intent
  • Ruthlessly eliminate the systemic impediments that hold them back

And if three points is too much, just start with your people – your most expensive component, and your weakest CI&S link.

We’ve lots of experience in helping leaders and organisations deliver these sort of ‘threat into opportunity’ transformations in Clear Star. If you want any help, advice or support then reach out to us.